Niagara Falls Reporter
Home | Archive / Search
JULY 28 - AUGUST 04, 2015

Taxpayer Watchdog Poloncarz Finds Sweetheart Assessment for Himself

By Tony Farina

JULY 28, 2015

Poloncarz property at 1500 Delaware Ave. assessed $50,000 below purchase price
Poloncarz property value seems whited out on his financial disclosure statement

It was not long ago that Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz urged the Amherst IDA to reject a law firm’s request for $550,000 in tax breaks for a proposed $4 million office expansion.

“Lawyer’s offices should not get tax breaks,” Poloncarz told the IDA even though 20 new jobs were being proposed as part of the expansion plan, a request the law firm later dropped.

And two years ago Poloncarz objected to tax breaks on a proposed $100 million building on the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus, suggesting a glorified medical office building was not worthy of taxpayer help.  Proponents were shocked by the criticism from the county executive to what they called a critical piece to the growth of the medical campus.

But while Poloncarz was billing himself as a taxpayer watchdog, in 2012 he made a pretty good real estate investment for himself with a very favorable assessment, purchasing what was described by realtors as a “classic four bedroom home with gorgeous refinished woodwork on the first floor with oak paneled walls in the dining room.”

The property, at 1500 Delaware Ave. in the city of Buffalo, was purchased by Poloncarz for $207,500 in July of 2012 while it was assessed at $157,000, some $50,000 under the purchase price and with an estimated value now by Click here to go to of at least $267,505.  It is still assessed at $157,000.

We asked the county executive’s office about the under-assessment, and his spokesman, Peter Anderson, responded in an email “the property is assessed (by the City of Buffalo) at the proper amount; it was purchased in 2012 and reassessed in 2013.”

Anderson is right about the city doing the assessment but he is wrong about a reassessment last year.  It did not happen and a citywide revaluation is under way and won’t be completed until December of 2016.  Anderson didn’t respond when I sent an email pointing out his misstatement on the reassessment.

“We’re in the process of a complete revaluation now,” said Martin Kennedy, city commissioner of assessments, who confirmed no reassessment was done last year.  I asked him about the low assessment for Poloncarz and he said it represents “fair value,” but also admitted, under questioning, that property values have increased, and that’s why the city is doing the revaluation.

Kennedy grudgingly conceded that property like 1500 Delaware, where similar nearby homes are for sale for as much as $349,000, is an example of why the city needs to get busy on its reassessment program. 

But in the meantime, Poloncarz is saving about $1,200 a year on city and county property taxes (since 2012) from what he could be paying if the house were assessed at the $207,500 purchase price.  The taxpayer watchdog is making out quite nicely, owning a property that appears to be as much as $110,505 under assessed—or put another way, being taxed on an assessed valuation of 58.7 percent of its actual or real valuation now.

It also appears Poloncarz is not exactly broadcasting his assessment as there is no figure included for 1500 Delaware under the category “Real Estate” on his county financial disclosure form. 

In fact, the disclosure form has several letters to select from to insert under the title “Category Amount” when it comes to property, with the letter “F” used for property of more than $100,000 value.  There is no letter under that category in Poloncarz’s disclosure form and it even appears as if something about letter size has been whited out on the form.

I sent an email to Poloncarz’s spokesman about the apparent white out on the ethics form and received no response.

The only gifts listed on the county executive’s ethics form is a “Gameball with name on it,” from the Buffalo Bills.  It is listed under the gift category for gifts which do not exceed $75 in value.

In the meantime, the earliest possible date when Poloncarz could face a property tax increase is July of 2017 after the city’s current revaluation is completed.  Pretty good investment for the taxpayer watchdog and you would never have any idea of the property value from his ethics statement which is supposed to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth about the officeholder’s financial investments.  Maybe just an oversight, but the apparent white out is hard to overlook.


Next Story >>






Paul Dyster: Incompetent at Every Level
Dyster Recycling Program a Bust; Numbers Show Chump Change Return
Dyster Engineering Disaster Here; City Engineer Job Remains Open
The Best and the Brightest? No, Just the Most Expensive
Senator Ortt Questions Cuomo Wage Hike
Waste is the Name of the Game for Dyster and His Casino Spending Plans
Residents of 72nd Street Dreading Third Winter With No Running Water
City Streets a Mess as Dyster’s Attention Turns to Cricket Field
Signs Point to Dyster Loss
Dyster’s Record as Crime Fighter Dismal, to Put it Very Charitably
Dyster and Touma Produce Stage Play-Story Here
Dementia Care Conference in Niagara County
State Audit Rejects Dyster’s Version of Fiscal Facts Dyster Blames State-Seneca Impasse For City Financial Woes
Dyster Orders up Sweet Job for SWEET Employee Brook D’Angelo
Alicia Laible Says City Should Be Run More Like Private Business
On the Campaign Trail
Only In NT: Vote for Real Public Servants this Year!
Death Notice
Facts are Facts Seneca , Albany Wins Big, Dyster is Small
Letters to the Editor
'Too White' Neighborhoods Slated for Change
Skrlin the Great Teaches PHD
Taxpayer Watchdog Poloncarz Finds Sweetheart Assessment for Himself
NT History Museum Book Sale Saturday
Grati Awarded Sass Scholarship
The Rookies -1
A Poem and Rhyme of Childish Nonsense, Mirth and Absolutely No Worth
City Hall Jokes

Contact Info

©2014 The Niagara Falls Reporter Inc.
POB 3083, Niagara Falls, N.Y. 14304
Phone: (716) 284-5595

Publisher and Editor in Chief: Frank Parlato
Managing Editor: Dr. Chitra Selvaraj
Senior Editor: Tony Farina