Niagara Falls Reporter
Home | Archive / Search
NOV 11- NOV 19, 2014

Income Equality Another
Name for Communism

By Anna M. Howard

November 11, 2014

This worker in Bangladesh makes a few pennies an hour. How come no one is seeking income equality for her?

In our day we would have called Gary H. Collins a communist. Collins, a lawyer and president of the Council for a Livable World, a political action committee devoted to nuclear disarmament, has written a book about government mandated "income equality" called "The Last Election."

According to a release his publicist sent us, Collins "believes that income inequality is the most important issue facing America today."

He quotes a Gallop Poll where he claims two out of three Americans are "dissatisfied" with wealth distribution in the U.S.

Wealth distribution is a term of art which implies it's government's job to take money from people who earned too much money and give it to those who did not earn as much even if they did not work for it.

This was once called communism.

"There is almost nothing happening to reverse the trend (of income inequality)," says Collins, lamenting that "top earners" continue to be the only group with income growth.

Gee top earners have income growth?

Why not become a top earner then?

Instead Collins wants to "shake up American politics" by "mobiliz(ing) voters around income inequality." Now here is a question for Collins: If it is morally right to have income equality, why limit it to America?

Why not strive for worldwide income equality?

What bleeding heart liberal would think in terms of only his own geographical boundaries?

According to Gallup, the median income worldwide is $10,000 per household.

In order to achieve true income equality, the average American would have to redistribute her income

above $10,000 to the poor around the world.

But Collins may not be advocating for worldwide income equality. He may want income equality only with those richer than he.

If Gallup polled Americans on welfare or minimum wage to ask if they would like to see the government require those who make 10 times what they receive on welfare or their minimum wage job share half their wealth with them, what do you think the poll results would be?

Now suppose these same people were asked if they would share half their welfare check with a poor family from Bhutan whose head of household makes four cents an hour, or split their minimum wage in half - and give it to a worker in China who make $1.19 an hour - what do you think Americans would poll about income equality?

Compared to a person in Bangladesh, working for nine cents an hour, and almost starving all the time, the average welfare recipient in America is 10 times richer. The welfare recipient is a rich person in his eyes, getting welfare for doing nothing, while he is making nine cents an hour slaving in the sun.

What Collins and the income redistributors forgets is that wealth is relative. Collins forgets that wealth is created by working, thinking, inventing, doing and exerting. Wealth is created.

Wealth is changing and moving, gained by one, lost by another. There is always wealth to be had, because people create it by working. Hard.

"That some should be rich shows that others may become rich, and hence is just encouragement to industry and enterprise," said Lincoln.

Sure opportunities are unequal, and some will work harder than others; some are smarter than others; luck is a factor.

Sometimes the harder you work, the luckier you become.

So why is that the income inequality proponents always want more income for them and less for others and never vice versa?

As a rule we don't support it.

Nevertheless, l there is one form of income equality that the Niagara Falls Reporter supports correcting: Politicians pay themselves pretty high salaries. They give themselves retirement benefits and perks that generally set their own wealth well above those who pay their salaries through mandatory taxes.

We support an income equality law that requires every politician from federal to local to earn the median income of the people they serve.

For instance the median income in Niagara Falls is $26,800. So elected and appointed city officials should earn $26,800.

The median income of all Americans is $51,017.

So Congressmen, who make $174,000, should take a $123,000 pat cut and get some true income equality.

And finally for all those who support income equality, such as Gary Collins, when these give a sizeable portion of their income to those around the world making far less, instead of trying to persuade lazy Americans to become communists, then, and only then, will we believe a word he has to say.





Reporter Proposes to Solve City Budget Woes
Touma Says He Would Cancel the Gov.’s Contest Before he Would Raise Taxes on Working People Here...
Choolokian Comments on Reporter Proposal
Income Equality Another Name for Communism
We Asked People What They Think About Proposed Tax Hike
Dyster Leads Cayuga Island Residents Down the Jayne Park Asphalt Path
Niagara Falls a ‘Most Dangerous’ City? Police Chief Here Disputes Conclusions
Thanks to Republican Control of State Senate Buffalo's Truck Pollution Less Likely to Become Lewiston's
"Buffalo Olmsted", Cuomo Sell Out Niagara Falls for Delaware North $$$
Does Dyster Incentive Have “Retire-Rehire” Agenda?
Will Kiedrowski be Next NT Mayor?
Music Video Targets Dyster’s Wanton Way of Spending
Big Bad Voodoo Daddy to Headline Memorial’s 2015 Premier
'Look Not to Government, Look Within,' says First Black Republican Female Congresswoman
Another Superb Doctor Joins the Staff At Memorial
Lawyers Offer Free Seminar on Preserving Assets on Medicaid
Even a spell check wouldn't have helped
Falls Man Continues to Send Cash To African Lonely Hearts Scammers
This Week in Stupid Crime
Letters to the Editor
Scrooge the Musical Coming to Lockport’s Palace Theater
Riviera to Host Chaplin Show
Khapra Beetle Intercepted
Bills, Sabres Continue Their Losing Ways Under Pegulas
Dyster Visits the Woodshed Jokes

Contact Info

©2014 The Niagara Falls Reporter Inc.
POB 3083, Niagara Falls, N.Y. 14304
Phone: (716) 284-5595

Publisher and Editor in Chief: Frank Parlato
Managing Editor: Dr. Chitra Selvaraj
Senior Editor: Tony Farina