Niagara Falls Reporter
Home | Archive / Search
JUNE 23 - JUNE 30, 2015

A Tale of Two Festivals Here;
One Gets Tax $$$ One Doesn't

By Mike Hudson

JUNE 23, 2015

The Niagara Falls Blues Festival is an annual event here. It's been held since 2008, organized by blues aficionado Toby Rotella, and generally subsidized at least in part by the taxpayers of Niagara Falls. This year, Rotella asked for and will receive $3,500 to stage the event.

By contrast, the Niagara Falls Music and Art Festival, an annual event organized by music and art lover Rick Crogan, is taking no public money whatsoever. After putting on his first festival several years ago, Crogan quickly realized there was money to be made here as a festival promoter, cancelled a plan that would have made his event a not for profit, and stopped asking for any subsidy.

Two different men, two different philosophies.

What is interesting is the way another man, Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster, has dealt with Rotella and Crogan. With Rotella, there hasn't been a problem.

He's received as much as $10,000 from the city in a year. One year, he was denied funding by a city Council majority opposed to Dyster's spendthrift ways but, to his credit, he sucked it up and his festival came off without a hitch.

Crogan, rejecting the public subsidy altogether, received much rougher treatment.

The name of Becky Marchetti is well known.

It was Marchetti's allegations against Crogan that led to the promoter being indicted on a couple of felony grand larceny charges in connection with the first Niagara Falls Music and Art Festival.

The case was so perverted that law enforcement following Marchetti's bogus allegations that Crogan operated a not-for-profit when it was always a for-profit company led mixed law enforcement to charge Crogan with a crime that is not a crime if his company was a for profit company, which it was.

When shamefaced prosecutors woke up and saw they had been had they ended up offering Crogan a single petit larceny misdemeanor, which Crogan, who had spent more than $24,000 in legal fees accepted in order to avoid a lengthy and expensive trial.

No sooner had Crogan been charged, however, than Mayor Paul Dyster all but convicted him on Facebook, and then went public with his intentions to "save" the Crogan festival from the man who invented it.

Dyster's attempted treachery hasn't been forgotten by Crogan.

This year, Joseph Calato, founder and owner of Regal Tip, the world famous drum stick and percussion supplies manufacturer, will be honored for his lifetime contribution to the music industry.

A veritable Who's Who of area political leaders attended to honor the 94-year-old drum maven and entrepreneur with proclamations, including U.S. Rep. Brian Higgins, state Rep. John Ceretto, county Legislators Dennis Virtuoso and Jason Zona and city Councilman and mayoral candidate Glenn Choolokian.

Conspicuously absent was Dyster, who was not invited to attend.

So Dyster will have to content himself at Toby Rotella's blues festival. The people of Niagara Falls will get to enjoy two fine events, one for free and one they're partially paying for.





Walker 'Votes' Not to Pay his Own Taxes While Upping Yours
Council Approves $100,000 for Summer Program That School Board Declined to Fund
Yes We Have No Appointment to the Finance Panel
Blues Fest Subsidy I Say No To
Delaware North Called Out at Pints Event
Hamister Seeking Big Return on Hyatt Place Deal
New City Policy Meant to Delay FOIL Requests
Serial Killer at Large in Niagara Falls? Authorities Don't Want to Say Yes But...
The King of Promoters, Rick Crogan Speaks About the Festival
Dyster Takes to Facebook to Steal Some of Crogan's Promotional Thunder
Council Candidate Laible's Relationship with Dyster Must Be Transparently Disclosed
Touma's "Parking Plan" Selling City Short
A Tale of Two Festivals Here; One Gets Tax $$$ One Doesn't
I Smell Something Rotten
Niagara Falls Memorial Receives Children's Health Home Designation
Niagara Falls Memorial Launches New P3 Center for Teens, Moms and Kids
National Fuel Skips Out on Taxes, Makes Life Miserable in Pendleton
More Tales from the Trail
Quinn Stays Cool Despite Criticism from Mills
Wheatfield Reader Loves Dyster's New Kayak
WNY Top High School Lacrosse Players Honored at Borrelli Awards Dinner
City Hall Jokes

Contact Info

©2014 The Niagara Falls Reporter Inc.
POB 3083, Niagara Falls, N.Y. 14304
Phone: (716) 284-5595

Publisher and Editor in Chief: Frank Parlato
Managing Editor: Dr. Chitra Selvaraj
Senior Editor: Tony Farina